The TOP FIVE Bagel Places in Monmouth County

Here are five top-rated bagel spots in Monmouth County worth checking out — each brings its own local flavor, handcrafted dough, and loyal following.

1. Town Bagel & Grill (Eatontown)

6

This popular spot at 37 NJ-35 in Eatontown pulls in a strong 4.6-star average from over 350 reviews. The “& Grill” part signals that in addition to excellent bagels, you’ll find hearty breakfast sandwiches and a sit-down feel. Great for a casual bagel stop with some variety.

2. Bagel Masters (Shrewsbury)

6

Located at 661 Broad St., Shrewsbury, Bagel Masters is known for hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels — the kind of old-school craftsmanship you don’t always find. The shop is repeatedly recognized on best-bagel lists for Monmouth County. 94.3 The Point+1

3. Hot Bagel Bakery (Oakhurst)

6

A longtime favorite at 67 Monmouth Rd #2, Oakhurst, this 4.4-star rated shop is beloved especially for its classic approach — boiled, crisp-edged bagels with a chewy interior. Many locals consider it one of the best in the county. Reddit+1

4. Tommy’s Bagels (Manalapan)

6

Right in your backyard at 130 NJ-33 #6 in Manalapan Township, Tommy’s Bagels boasts a 4.7-star average from nearly 300 reviews. It’s a strong neighborhood option when you want high-quality bagels without heading far.

5. The Bagel Nook (Atlantic Highlands / Freehold area)

6

While their main listing is at 2345 NJ-36 in Atlantic Highlands, they also serve Freehold area. The Bagel Nook stands out for inventive bagel flavors and has been featured in national food-media roundups. thebagelnook.com+1